Skip to main content

En Banc Category

Negotiating Against Yourself: Flawed Negotiating Process Leads Chancery Court to Deny M&F-Premised Motion to Dismiss

Sep. 22, 2020—Robert S. Reder & Matthew K. Vallade | 73 Vand. L. Rev. En Banc 213 (2020) | “In Alon USA, a target company minority stockholder challenged a transaction where a stockholder owning ‘48% [of the] equity interest’ in the target purchased the remainder of the outstanding stock via a merger transaction. In sorting out this...

Read more


Our Trade Law System

Jun. 5, 2020—Kathleen Claussen | 73 Vand. L. Rev. En Banc 195 (2020) | In Misaligned Lawmaking, Timothy Meyer identifies a major problem in U.S. trade law design. Professor Meyer argues that there is a misalignment between trade liberalization laws—laws that enable the executive branch to lower trade barriers with other countries—and trade adjustment assistance laws—laws that...

Read more


Irrational Inequality: The Role of Fact-Based Review in Equality Change

May. 27, 2020—Katie Eyer | 73 Vand. L. Rev. En Banc 177 (2020) | In Broken Records: Reconceptualizing Rational Basis Review to Address “Alternative Facts” in the Legislative Process, Joseph Landau offers an important exposition of how legislative records “predicated on a false factual foundation” are, and ought to be, treated by constitutional equality law. As Landau...

Read more


Taking an Interest in Inmate Trust Accounts

May. 27, 2020—Charlotte Elam | 73 Vand. L. Rev. En Banc 143 (2020) | The Fifth Amendment’s Takings Clause is generally unconcerned about the size of property taken. But is it more concerned about the person from whom the property is taken? When that person is a prisoner, courts have found the relevance of the Takings Clause...

Read more


Making Litigating Citizenship More Fair

May. 14, 2020—Ming H. Chen | 73 Vand. L. Rev. En Banc 133 (2020) | In Litigating Citizenship, Cassandra Burke Robertson and Irina D. Manta chart the contours of expanding immigration enforcement in the Trump administration: from criminal aliens and illegal aliens, to legal immigrants, to naturalized citizens. In their own words, their interest is “How do...

Read more


Delaware Supreme Court Approves Federal Forum Selection Provision for Securities Act Claims

May. 7, 2020—Robert S. Reder | 73 Vand. L. Rev. En Banc 123 (2020) | “In 2018, the Delaware Court of Chancery (“Chancery Court”) confronted the question of whether a corporation could validly adopt an exclusive forum selection provision requiring that claims under the Securities Act of 1933 (“Securities Act”) be brought in federal rather than state...

Read more


Chancery Court Dismisses Breach of Fiduciary Duty Claims Against Target Company Directors Despite Unavailability of Corwin Defense

May. 4, 2020—Robert S. Reder & Lorin Hom | 73 Vand. L. Rev. En Banc 111 (2020) | “In Morrison III, Vice Chancellor Glasscock again dismissed the claims of fiduciary breach brought against all but one of the named target company directors, citing failure by plaintiff to adequately plead facts satisfying the high bar imposed by an...

Read more


Chancery Court Denies Rescission of Merger Agreement Where “Indispensable” Company Stockholders Not Named as Parties to Litigation

Apr. 21, 2020—Robert S. Reder & Jacob R. Haskins | 73 Vand. L. Rev. En Banc 105 (2020) | It is customary, when a private corporation with numerous stockholders is sold, for a representative to be appointed to act on behalf of the stockholders if a dispute arises post-closing with respect to a purchase price adjustment or...

Read more


Norcraft Appraisal: Chancery Court Gives No Weight to Deal Price Negotiated in a Conflicted CEO-Led Transaction with a Flawed Sales Process

Apr. 21, 2020—Robert S. Reder & Szymon S. Barnas | 73 Vand. L. Rev. En Banc. 93 (2020) | “[I]n Blueblade Capital Opportunities LLC v. Norcraft Companies, Inc., No. CV 11184-VCS, 2018 WL 3602940 (Del. Ch. July 27, 2018) (hereinafter “Norcraft Appraisal Action”), the Chancery Court determined that neither the deal price produced by the sales process...

Read more


In Defense of Excellence

Jan. 29, 2020—Jasper L. Tran | 73 Vand. L. Rev. En Banc 71 | Reviewed: Anthony T. Kronman, THE ASSAULT ON AMERICAN EXCELLENCE, Free Press 2019. Pp. 272. $27.00 Hardcover. “Up until recently, excellence had been an educational ideal. At the founding of the Catholic University of Ireland in 1852, John Henry Newman envisioned a university as a...

Read more


Chancery Court Indicates Willingness to Extend M&F to Compensation Award to Controlling Stockholder

Jan. 28, 2020—Robert S. Reder & Alexandra N. Bakalar | 73 Vand. L. Rev. En Banc 61 (2020) | PDF Download Link “Delaware courts are tasked with reviewing breach of fiduciary duty claims arising from a variety of commercial transactions. No matter the type of transaction, however, the standard of review applied by the court is all-important...

Read more


Chancery Court Finds Notice to Non-Consenting Stockholders Not a Precondition to an Effective Majority Written Consent

Jan. 15, 2020—Robert S. Reder & Jake Haskins | 73 Vand. L. Rev. En Banc. 53 | PDF Download Link “[N]otice issues were addressed by the Delaware Court of Chancery (“Chancery Court”) in Brown v. Kellar, C.A. No. 2018-0687-MTZ, 2018 WL 6721263 (Del. Ch. Dec. 21, 2018). First, Vice Chancellor Morgan T. Zurn considered whether “prompt notice”...

Read more


Chancery Court Rejects Target Company Claim That Termination Fee Was Jilted Merger Partner’s Exclusive Remedy

Jan. 15, 2020—Robert S. Reder & Alexandra Sasha Gombar | 73 Vand. L. Rev. En Banc 45 | PDF Download Link “Recently, in Genuine Parts Co. v. Essendant Inc., C.A. No. 2018-0730-JRS, 2019 WL 4257160 (Del. Ch. Sept. 9, 2019) (“Genuine Parts”), the Chancery Court had another opportunity to analyze standard public merger agreement provisions. Vice Chancellor...

Read more


Chancery Court Refuses Pleading Stage Dismissal Under Corwin When Stockholders Not Fully Informed of Long-Overdue Financial Restatement

Jan. 15, 2020—Robert S. Reder & Amanda M. Mitchell | 73 Vand. L. Rev. En Banc 35 | PDF Download Link “The factual bases underlying Vice Chancellor Slights’s refusal to entertain a Corwin defense at the pleading stage in Tangoe—delayed Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) filings and inadequate financial statement disclosures to stockholders—are similar to the factual...

Read more


Chancery Court Refuses to Dismiss Action to Enforce Post-Merger Covenant Due to Ambiguities in Merger Agreement

Jan. 15, 2020—Robert S. Reder & Faisal Q. Haider | 73 Vand. L. Rev. En Banc 27 | PDF Download Link “Notwithstanding the disavowal of covenant survival and third-party beneficiary rights, there are circumstances in which publicly traded targets bargain for post-merger covenants in public merger agreements. For instance, where a significant amount of acquiring company stock...

Read more


Chancery Court Declines to Apply Corwin at Pleading Stage to “Cleanse” Breach of Fiduciary Duty Claim Due to Material Non-Disclosures

Jan. 15, 2020—Robert S. Reder & Robert W. Dillard | 73 Vand. L. Rev. En Banc 17 | PDF Download Link “In late 2018, the Delaware Court of Chancery (the “Chancery Court”) once again denied pleading-stage application of Corwin when faced with well-pled allegations a stockholder vote was not fully informed. In In re Xura, Inc. Stockholder...

Read more